Kaufman Lab · AI architecture
Articles · AI assistants

Which AI is best for work: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Alice?

There is no single best AI for work. In the composite index on October 31, 2026, Gemini, Claude and ChatGPT were two points apart, and in website layout on Arena, Claude and ChatGPT were ahead. Alice, Yandex's AI assistant, did not make the top rows, but it works in Russia. Compare two AI models on your own task on the Arena site: according to a guide from an AI tools directory dated August 2025, it is free and needs no sign-up.

Roman Kaufman, founder of Kaufman Lab · Data as of: October 2026

A composite index window for 10/31/2026 with Gemini 4 Carbon first, while an old 10/17/2026 card with Claude has fallen out. Text: Which AI is best? No single best AI
Composite index leaders: Claude was first on October 17, Gemini on October 31

A student is building their own website and is ready to pay for one subscription. In mid-October, the composite index ranked Claude first. By the end of the month, Gemini was first. Claude did not lose a single point in that time. In October 2026, the reviews you find in search were writing about older versions. So which table should you trust when you pay out of your own pocket?

Each table has its own order

Three open tables from October name different leaders, because they measure different things. The Artificial Analysis composite index adds up a score from many tests, from code to hard exams. In the Arena blind vote, a person sees two answers without names and picks the better one. WebDev works the same way, only people vote on website layouts.

Table and dateWho is firstWhere GPT is
Composite index of 86 models, October 31, 2026Gemini 4 Carbon, 59 points; Claude Opus 5.5, 58GPT-6 Astra, 57 points
Arena vote, October 15, 2026Gemini 4 Argon; Claude Opus 5.5 thirdbest GPT in 21st place
Arena WebDev, October 16, 2026Claude Opus 5.5GPT-6 Astra second

Gemini 4 Carbon, first in the index, is open only to selected cybersecurity specialists. It is not in the Gemini app or the API, an AI consulting firm wrote on October 29, 2026. So you have to choose from the second row down.

People's votes show whose answer they liked, not whose answer is correct. We covered how AI finds facts in a separate article.

For websites, the order is different. In the October 15 vote, Gemini 4 Argon was first, but in WebDev a day later Argon was only ninth. So name your task first, then open the table for that task.

In Russia, access matters before quality

Neither OpenAI nor Anthropic nor Google includes Russia in its lists of countries for ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. The OpenAI help page, updated in October 2026, says that signing in from a country not on the list can lead to the account being blocked or suspended. A strong model will not help if the account is closed along with the paid subscription.

Anthropic's country rules, in the version in force from November 12, 2026, also close Claude to companies registered or headquartered in a country that is not allowed. Even an employee abroad will not help a Russian company. Google's list of countries for the Gemini API and AI Studio, dated October 22, 2026, does not include Russia. That list is for developers, not for the app.

Alice from Yandex opens at alice.yandex.ru, in the app and in Yandex search, the Russian tech site 3DNews wrote on October 28, 2025. It is not in the top rows of the Arena tables, and we did not find a reliable comparison of Alice with the three leaders.

First place changed in two weeks

Trust the date of the table, not the brand. On October 17, 2026, the Developers Digest summary ranked Claude Opus 5.5 first in the index with 58 points. On October 31, Gemini 4 Carbon took first place with 59. Google unveiled it on October 28. A new model took first place.

In October 2026, our lab worked with models from two companies, Claude and GPT-6 Astra. We hold on to a way of working, not to a brand. Our site was built with AI. The code goes out of date with every generation of models, but the method does not. Your choice from last week may be out of date too.

Compare two AI models on your task

The table from October 31 gives you a short list. Your task decides. Testing two candidates takes one evening.

  1. Choose a table on arena.ai. For a website, you need WebDev. For text, you need the vote. Write down the top two models you can access.
  2. Give both of them the same task in the "Side by Side" tab, and the answers will appear next to each other. According to the same directory's guide from August 20, 2025, this is free and needs no login, but the tab may have been renamed. Write down the winner and the date, the way the October 17 summary recorded its own.
  3. Check your country before you pay. If you are in Russia, ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini are not on the lists, and of the four AI models in this article, Alice is the one left. If not, the winner of step 2 decides.

For a website, compare Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6 Astra, first and second in WebDev. For text, pair Gemini 4 Argon and Claude Opus 5.5, first and third in the October 15 vote. We covered how to write an article with AI separately. If you are choosing an AI for a company, first remember Anthropic's rule about companies and decide what data to upload to AI.

Frequently asked questions

Which GPT version is best, and do you need the paid one?

In the composite index on October 31, 2026, OpenAI's highest model is GPT-6 Astra with 57 points. GPT-6.1 Sol, with 55 points, completes the index task almost five times cheaper, $1.27 versus $6.24. The business channel Fox Business wrote on September 3, 2026, that Astra was coming to the ChatGPT Plus, Pro, Business and Enterprise plans. The free plan was not on that list, so Astra in ChatGPT was promised only to paid plans.

Which Claude is best?

Among Claude models, Opus 5.5 is the strongest. In October 2026, it was first in WebDev and scored 58 points in the composite index. Claude Sonnet 5.5 was third in WebDev on October 16, right after GPT-6 Astra.

A question about this article?

Message me on Telegram: I answer myself, look at your task and tell you which of this fits it.

Message on Telegram→
More articles
↑ top